69 Supernatural Gifts for the Mega Fan That Lost Their Shoe

TheGiftYak curates unique gifts and is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Looking for a gift to appeal to even the biggest Supernatural TV super fan? Look no further! Whether it’s television show memorabilia, posters or fan art, there is something here for even the most extreme fan. Make someone’s day and remind them why they love Supernatural with a unique gift!

Supernatural Subscription Box
Celebrate the seasons with these 4 unique Supernatural Subscription Boxes! Filled with 100% exclusive items, you'll have plenty of work to do to enjoy your new merchandise! With past items including vinyl figurines, blankets, ceramic mugs, posters, and more- you'll be able to proudly proclaim your love of Dean, Sam, and Cass to the entire Supernatural world.

Funko Pop Sam Action Figure
You'll be shouting 'It's Spectacu-kacu-lar!' when you unwrap your new Sam Winchester Action Figure from Funko Pop. Based on Jared Padalecki's character from the hit TV show Supernatural, this vinyl figure is great for fans and collectors alike. Complete your collection with the other Winchester brother Dean, and the Angel Castiel.


AMT 1967 Chevy Impala Model Kit
Own your own version of Dean's Baby with this Supernatural themed 1967 Chevy Impala Model Kit. This 1/25 scale model kit has a skill level of 2 and requires paint and glue to construct. Carefully crafted after the show's iconic ride, this model boasts Kansas license plates, spotlights, bumper guards, and more.

Color Changing Mug
Take your morning coffee demon hunting with this color-changing Supernatural Mug. This 12-ounce ceramic mug reveals a hidden image once filled with hot liquid. As your drink cools, it turns back to black! To preserve the color-changing abilities, it is recommended to hand wash this mug and not microwave it.

Winchester Brothers T-Shirt
Show off your pride in the Winchester Family Business with this Supernatural Anti-Possession T-Shirt. Supernatural is the hit TV show that follows the Winchester brothers Dean and Sam as they continue the family business of Saving People and Hunting Things, specifically demons. A great shirt to wear to Expo's, Cons, and more, this 100% cotton shirt will keep you comfy all day long.

Funko Pop Dean Action Figure
Show off your favorite demon-hunter turned demon with this Dean Winchester Action Figure from Funko Pop. Based on Jensen Ackles' character from the hit TV show Supernatural, this vinyl figure is great for fans and collectors alike. Complete your collection with the other Winchester brother Sam, and the Angel Castiel.

John Winchester Official Journal Replica
Own an iconic prop from the hit TV Show Supernatural with your own John Winchester Journal Replica. This 6x9 faux leather journal includes notes, details, and drawings from the show as well as 5 note-worthy news articles. A must-have for any Supernatural fan, you'll be able to fill this journal with your own adventures.

Metal Stamped License Plates
If you're not the Driver, shut your cakehole and show off these Metal Stamped Supernatural Replica License Plates. These aluminum plates are perfect recreations of the Kansas and Ohio license plates used on Dean Winchester's 1967 Impala. Hang them on your wall, or keep them in your own car as a way to show off your love of the Supernatural.

Driver Picks the Music Keyring
Keep your keys close by, and keep the shotgun rider in check with this Driver Picks the Music Keyring. Inspired by Dean's classic like 'Driver Picks the Music, Shotgun Shuts His Cakehole.' this engraved keychain also has a charm of the Winchester brothers iconic 1967 Impala.

Winchester Brothers Ankle Socks
Keep your toes warm as you battle otherworldly forces with these Supernatural themed Winchester Brother Ankle Socks. These officially licensed socks fit shoe sizes 4-10 in US Women. With fun and unique decorations highlighting your favorite monster-hunting brothers, these socks are sure to be a catch.

Sam Winchester Hoodie
Stay warm while hunting monsters with this Unisex Sam Winchester Hoodie. Made of a 50-50 cotton-polyester blend this hoodie comfy hoodie has a kangaroo pocket to keep your hands warm, and essentials nearby. Perfect for days where you want to lounge in warmth and comfort.

Swappable Grip for Phone and Tablets
Stop dropping your electronics with this Swappable PopSockets Grip for Phones and Tablets. Add a single Pop Socket, or a pair of them to the back of your electronic devices to help your phone or tablet, stay up on its own, help you keep a grip on it, or just fiddle with it during the day.

Women's Reusable Black Mask
Protect your face from frost, fog, or allergens with this reusable black face mask. Made from lightweight polyester, this breathable mask can be machine washed and dried. This mask is ideal for most teens and adults. Its stretchable elastic ear loops give you comfort, while it's fun print helps make a statement.

Men's Mugshot T-shirt
Rep your favorite brothers with this Supernatural Winchester Brothers Mugshot Graphic T-Shirt. Based on the main characters of the hit TV show. This T-shirt is made with the super-soft cotton and offers a stretchy but slim fit, so you might want to order a size up. Available in Black, White, and Gray.

Eternal War Eyeshadow Palette
Put on our war paint with this Supernatural Eternal War Eyeshadow Palette. This 20-color palette brings the aesthetic of Good Vs. Evil right onto your makeup brushes! With 10 soft, pastel colors for Good and 10 vibrant, bold colors for Bad - your makeup looks are sure to be inspiring or fear-inducing.

Dean Plush Doll
Have your own version of Dean Winchester to snuggle with at night with Quantum Mechanix 8-inch plush Dean Winchester doll. Based on Jensen Ackles character in the hit TV show. The doll is styled in jeans, a burgundy shirt, a jacket, and a signature smirk. The perfect gift for the Supernatural fan in your life.

Pocket Knife with Glass Breaker
Stay ready and protected with this Supernatural Demon Trap Pocket Knife with Glass Breaker. The laser engraved wood has a circular symbol familiar to any Supernatural fan, while also boasting a seatbelt cutter and glass breaker. A must-have for car and roadside safety, this is the perfect gift for a Supernatural fan before they hit the road.

Family Don't End with Blood Paperback
With three People's Choice Awards, Supernatural is one of the most popular Sci-Fi/Fantasy TV shows. With its message of 'always keep fighting' and catchphrase, 'Family don't end with blood' this book showcases how Supernatural has changed the lives of fans and cast members alike. Written and Edited by clinical psychologist Lynn S. Zubernis.

Daily Planner and Notepads
Stay organized for your next hunting trip with this 3-Pack Supernatural Daily Planner and Notepad Set. The planner includes a general track, meal planning, and notes sections while the notepad is the perfect place to scribble down inspiration and notes as they come. The Magnetized To-Do list is perfect for the fridge, or wall whenever you need to keep track of another task.

Baby with Dean Funko Pop Exclusive
Jump in and hang out tight, as the Funko Exclusive Dean Winchester and his Baby 1967 Chevy Impala slide over to your house. Styled after the long-running TV show Supernatural, this exclusive Funko set celebrates Dean Winchester the Demon Hunter, and the car his Father gave him within the series.

Collector's Edition Calendar
Spend the year on the hunt with the Winchester Brothers through this Collector's Edition Supernatural Calendar. With twelve beautiful art prints for each month of the year, and two exclusive 8x10 posters this uniquely styled calendar provides you with a lovely gift box for safekeeping.

Single Edition Supernatural Magazine
Own a piece of Entertainment Weekly Magazine History with this Collector's Edition 2020 Ultimate Guide to Supernatural. Published in the Summer of 2020 this Magazine includes a guide to all 15 seasons of the long-running show as well as exclusive interviews with the main cast.

Winchester Brothers Pill Case
Let your favorite demon-hunting duo keep your daily medication safe with this Winchester Brothers Pill Case. Based on the hit TV show Supernatural, this resin-topped chrome metal tin is perfect for holding medications, coins, trinkets, and more. It's the ideal size for your jacket pocket or even a small purse.

License Plate Frame
Protect your license plate while repping the family business with this unique Supernatural License Plate Frame. Made of durable plastic, this UV and Water-Resistant frame won't fade or smear no matter what the adventure. Fashioned after standard North American plates, this frame has four mounting holes and cut-out corners for tags and registration stickers.

Vinyl Wall Clock
Keep track of the last time Dad went on a hunting trip with this Supernatural Vinyl Art Wall Clock. This AA-battery run clock is quiet so it won't disturb you during the day or keep you up at night. Bring some modern flair to your home with this Recycled Vinyl LP Wall Art Clock.

Photo Fashion Hoodie
Let everyone know you're part of the hunt with this Unisex Supernatural Fashion Photo Hoodie. Made from breathable polyester, this machine-washable hoodie features a kangaroo pocket to keep your hands warm, and your essentials nearby at all times. Suitable from loungewear to sportswear, these hoodies are as versatile as the brothers on them.

Signed Actor Photo Reprint
Complete your collection with a piece of Supernatural TV history with this Signed Supernatural Photo Reprint featuring Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki. This 8x10 reprinting is the perfect Birthday, Valentine's, or Just Because gift for the Supernatural fan in your life. Frame not included.

Family Don't End with Blood Keychain
Remind your best friend that they're family too with this Family Don't End with Blood Keychain. Based on the hit TV show Supernatural, which follows the Winchester brothers as they continue the family demon-hunting business. This hand-stamped stainless steel keyring includes a pentagram charm and comes in a velvet pouch.

Signed TV Script Reprint
Complete your collection with a piece of Supernatural TV history with this Signed Supernatural TV Show Script Reprint. This 8.5 x 11 reprint features the signatures of; Jensen Ackles, Jared Padalecki, Misha Collins, and Jeffrey Dean Morgan. Printed on high-quality FSC-certified paper with a thick cardstock cover and backing. Frame not included.

5th Season DVD Collector's Edition
Turn down the lights and get ready for a demon-hunting marathon with Supernatural Season 5's Collector's Edition DVD. This 22-episode season includes hit titles such as, 'Sympathy for the Devil' 'Changing Channels' 'The Real Ghostbusters' 'My Bloody Valentine' 'Two Minutes to Midnight' and 'Swan Song'.

Demon Trap Lighter
Stay ready and protected with this Supernatural Demon Trap Lighter. The router engraved metal has a circular symbol familiar to any Supernatural fan, while it's less than 3.5-inch size allows you to easily slip this lighter into your pant, shirt, or jacket pocket.

Angel Wing Charm Necklace
Complete your Supernatural cosplay outfit with this Angel Wing Hunter Necklace. The 24-inch alloy chain boasts a pentagram pendant, a bottle of salt, and an angel wing. Based on the long-running hit TV show, this necklace is the perfect accessory, from cosplay to every day!

Pop Quiz Trivia Deck
Bring some Supernatural fun to your next game night with the Supernatural Pop Quiz Trivia Deck. Created by Chip Carter, author of the Obsessed With Star Trek trivia book, this trivia book is a great way to test your knowledge of Supernatural starting from Episode one!

Paperback Puzzle Book
Keep boredom at bay for hours with this Supernatural Puzzle Book. Filled with Word Search, Word Scrambles, Missing Letter Puzzles, and Trivia questions it's a perfect way to exercise your brain while still enjoying your favorite TV show. This paperback book measures 8.5 x 11 inches, so it's easy to slip into your backpack or leave on your bedside table.

64 Impala Men's T-shirt
Rep your favorite Baby with this 1964 Chevy Impala Lowrider T-Shirt. Inspired by Dean Winchester's iconic vehicle in the hit TV show Supernatural, this cotton t-shirt is lightweight with a classic fit. Ideal for lounging, attending cons, or hunting down demons. Machine wash cold, Low heat.

Oven Mitt Set
Bring some personality to your kitchen with these unique Supernatural-themed Oven Mitt and Potholder Set. With heat resistance of up to 356 degrees, this oven mitt and potholder set will keep your hands safe from burns and blisters as you bake, cook, or bar-b-que. With convenient loops to hang on hooks, tables, or drawers - this set is sure to be put to good use.

Waterproof Shower Curtain
Share your love of the Winchester Brothers with your very own Supernatural Driver Picks the Music Shower Curtain. Perfect for a college student, this shower curtain will sure to be a big hit in the dorms. Machine washable, this easy-to-install shower curtain includes 12 free hooks to get you started.

Tapestry Wall Hanging
Show off your love of Supernatural with this 60x50 inch tapestry inspired by the hit TV show. Boasting the 3 main characters Dean, Sam, and Castiel; this polyester tapestry is durable enough for indoor or outdoor use. Whether you're using it as a wall hanging, a picnic blanket, or a bedcover, this machine-washable tapestry will bring your favorite TV show to life.

Lightweight Blanket
Give your Supernatural lover a blanket that will keep them all warm and snuggly. Have them wrapped in your love for every season. This lightweight and ultra soft blanket is the perfect gift idea for binge watching. Easy care and easy wash makes it an easy gift choice.

Castiel Plush Doll
Have your own guardian with Quantum Mechanix 18-inch plush Castiel doll. Based on Misha Collins's character in the hit TV show Supernatural. The doll comes styled in slacks, a dress shirt, tie, wings, and his trademark trench coat. The perfect gift for the Supernatural fan in your life.

Hardcover Official Cookbook
Perfect for novices and professionals alike, the Official Supernatural Cookbooks is a must-have for any demon-hunting kitchen. Filled with over 50 delicious recipes inspired by the hit TV show Supernatural, you'll learn to make Burgers, Pies, and more. Written by food blogger Julie Tremaine this 128-page cookbook is the perfect housewarming gift.

Winchester Brothers Wall Clock
Keep track of your next hunting trip with this Vinyl Winchester Brothers Wall Clock. Perfect for birthdays, housewarming, and graduations this 100% Vinyl Wall Clock can be used functionally or simply for decor. With laser-cuttings of the Winchester Brothers, their Chevy Impala, and a blazing Pentagram you'll be able to bring a piece of the Supernatural into your own home.

Supernatural Quote Mug
Keep your mornings inspired with this 11-Ounce Supernatural Quote Mug. Covered in iconic phrases from the hit TV show, this ceramic mug is microwave-safe and a wonderful conversational piece for Dorms, School, and the Office. An ideal low-key fan piece, this mug is both functional and fun.

Sam and Dean Wall Poster
Pay homage to your favorite demon-hunting brother duo with this Sam & Dean Winchester Wall Poster. This poster is printed on FSC-Certified Gloss Paper. This officially licensed poster can be placed in a frame, or hung directly onto your wall with pins, clips, tacks, or glue strips.

Life Size Sam Cardboard Cutout
Give them the gift of Sam Winchester with this Life-Size Cardboard Cut-Out. Based on Jared Padalecki's character from the hit CW TV show this cutout measures 76-inches high and 25-inches wide. From bedroom decorations to house party photo-ops, this cutout will bring a smile to the face of all who come across it.

Dean Art Print Poster
Keep the inspiring words of Dean Winchester somewhere you can always see them, with this 'Love Me Some Pie' Art Print Poster. The silhouette of Dean Winchester is filled with iconic phrases and saying the character has said over the long-running TV show Supernatural. This professionally printed and framed art print is the perfect addition to any family or living room or bedroom.

Pencil Pouch with Zipper
Keep your backpack organized in style with this Zippered Winchester Brothers Pencil Pouch. Measuring approximately 8 x 6 inches this small pouch can easily be tossed in your backpack, briefcase, or purse. This product is officially licensed by Warner Pictures and made in the United States.

Supernatural Complete Series DVD Set
On days when you're just needing something a bit paranormal, pop in one of your favorite episodes of Supernatural thanks to this Complete DVD Series. Featuring all 15 seasons, this set contains more than 80 DVDs filled with all of your favorite episodes. This long-running CW TV show has been a hit with viewers and is sure to bring you hours of fun.

Supernatural: Nevermore Paperback
Based on the Hit CW TV Show Supernatural, Nevermore is an untold adventure of the iconic Winchester Brothers. While in New York, the brothers are hunting a series of killings based on the works of Edgar Allan Poe - that are happening right near the famous authors' house. Follow Sam and Dead as they unravel the mystery in Nevermore.

Hardcover Ruled Journal
Keep notes of your own hunting trip with this Supernatural, John Winchester Hardcover Ruled Journal. Inspired by the hit CW TV show, this notebook contains pages of John's notes, as well as space for you to write your own. This 192-page journal is acid-free and made of heavy stock paper so you can use pen, ink, or marker without bleeding through.

Supernatural Card Game
Bring some Supernatural fun to your next poker night with Cryptozoic Supernatural Playing Card Game. This deck of cards offers a unique twist, with sigils and iconography familiar to fans of the show. A high-quality image of Sam, Dean and Castiel grace the deck back - making game night that much more interesting.

Driver Picks the Music T-shirt
Let everyone know the rules of the road with this Driver Picks the Music Supernatural T-Shirt. Supernatural follows the Winchester brothers Dean and Sam as they continue the family business of Saving People and Hunting Things, specifically demons. A great shirt to wear to Expo's, Cons, and more, this 100% cotton shirt will keep you comfy all day long.

Buckle Down Seatbelt
Show off your style with this Buckle-Down Seatbelt Belt inspired by the hit TV show Supernatural. Supernatural follows the Winchester brothers Dean and Sam as they continue the family business of Saving People and Hunting Things, specifically demons. Made from 100% polyester, please note this belt is meant for fashion and is not an alternative to wearing a seatbelt inside of a vehicle.

Official Coloring Book
Keep boredom away for hours with this Official Supernatural Coloring Book by Insight Editions. This 96-page coloring book is filled with detailed illustrations of the cast, characters, motifs, and scenes from the hit TV show. Give the gift of fun to a Supernatural fan in your life with this unique coloring book.

Makeup Bag
Who said you can't look good while saving people and hunting things? Keep your daily makeup needs organized in this Zippered Canvas Supernatural Make-up Bag. Emblazoned with the Winchester Brothers and an iconic sun sigil, this officially licensed bag measures approximately 8x6 inches. Machine wash.

Retractable Lanyard for ID Cards
Keep your ID safe, and close by when you need it with this Supernatural Winchester Brothers Retractable Lanyard. This fully-rotatable alligator-style clip-on allows you to put your ID anywhere on your person, without worry. Its 3-foot long reel gives you the flexibility to maneuver around.

Impala Reusable Grocery Bag
Stroll the produce aisle in style with this 1967 Impala Reusable Grocery Tote Bag. Whether you're using it at the grocery store, the farmers market or to carry your lunch this durable tote bag is a great conversation starter about your favorite TV show!

Women's Coin Purse
Keep your change in one place with this Supernatural Themed Change Purse Wallet. Measuring about 4 x 4 inches, this wallet can hold coins, cards, lipstick, and other little knick-knacks. Perfect for traveling, the pouch can be tucked in a pocket on your person, or as a pouch in a larger bag.

Saving People Mouse Pad
Upgrade your gaming station to part of the family business with this Supernatural Saving People Hunting Things themed Mouse Pad. The non-slip rubber mat will protect your desk from scratches, spills, and condensation, as well as ensure a smooth surface to easily control your mouse.

Life Size Dean Cardboard Cutout
Give them the gift of Dean Winchester with this Life-Size Cardboard Cut-Out. Based on Jensen Ackles' character from the hit CW TV show this cutout measures 73-inches high and 24-inches wide. From bedroom decorations to house party photo-ops, this cutout will bring a smile to the face of all who come across it.

Mugshot Men's Billfold
Rep your favorite brother duo with this Supernatural Winchester Brothers Mugshot Billfold. Crafted from vegan leather, this wallet features a standard billfold, 5 card slots, and a windowed ID holder. Inspired by the hit CW TV Show Supernatural, this wallet is a must-have for any fan of the Winchester family business.

Anti-Possession Ring
Keep demons, ghouls, and ghosts at bay with this Supernatural Devil's Trap Anti-Possession ring. Made from stainless steel, this high-quality ring won't tarnish or rust. The ideal birthday, holiday, or just because gift for the Winchester fan in your life, this ring comes in a velvet jewelry bag.

Funko Pop Castiel with Wings
Unwrap your own personal guardian angel with this Castiel Funko Pop. Based on Misha Collins's character in the hit TV show Supernatural, this vinyl figure is great for fans and collectors alike. The figurine is styled in slacks, a dress shirt, tie, wings, and Castiel's trademark trench coat. Complete your collection with the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean.

Rubber Bumper iPhone Case
Keep your iPhone safe and show off your personality with this Supernatural themed Rubber Bump Phone Case. Made from flexible plastic this case will protect your phone from everyday wear and tear. With different sizing options, you can protect iPhones ranging from 8 to 11 Pro Max with its precise cutouts for ports, headphone jacks, buttons, and more.

Family Business Metal Sign
Show off your pride in the Winchester Family Business with your very own Supernatural 1967 Chevy Impala Metal Vanity License Plate. Made of solid aluminum, this durable and customizable sign is fashioned after standard North American plates,(6 x 12 inches) and has four mounting holes.

Mystery Poster Bundle
Experience the joy and anticipation of Christmas morning any day with this Supernatural Mystery Poster Set. Each bundle randomly selects 4 out of 20 Supernatural themed posters to share! With characters such as Sam, Dean, Crowley, Castiel, and more it's a wonderful way to treat yourself or a friend!

Supernatural Word Art Print
They say a picture is worth a thousand words, but this picture might be worth more! Made completely out of phrases, words, and sayings from the hit Tv Show this Supernatural Word Art Print measures 11 x 17 and depicts Sam and Dean Winchester in front of their '67 Impala.

Funko Pop Castiel
Unwrap your own personal guardian angel with this Castiel Funko Pop. Based on Misha Collins's character in the hit TV show Supernatural, this vinyl figure is great for fans and collectors alike. The figurine is styled in slacks, a dress shirt, tie, and trademark trench coat. Complete your collection with the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean.